Subject:SCMP / AP: Vatican negotiator says deal with China on nominating bishops was basis for ‘more concrete dialogue’
South China Morning Post
* Archbishop Claudio Maria Celli denies agreement was a sell-out of China’s underground church, but admits there is a long way to go
* China’s 12 million Catholics are split between government-backed group and underground church whose priests and parishioners are detained and harassed
Published: 1:58pm, 26 Mar, 2019
The Vatican official who negotiated a landmark agreement between the Holy See and China on bishop nominations said on Monday that the path to normalising Catholic life in the country was “still long” but that a new future was now possible.
Speaking in public for the first time since the accord was signed on September 22, Archbishop Claudio Maria Celli revealed details of his four-decade effort to heal the rift with China while attending a book launch.
Celli choked up at times, recalling the suffering he had seen while meeting clandestine bishops, as well as the “profound suffering” of illegitimate bishops forced to accept episcopal consecration without papal consent.
Italian Premier Giuseppe Conte, fresh from a visit to Italy by Chinese President Xi Jinping and the signing of an agreement to support Beijing’s infrastructure strategy the “Belt and Road Initiative”, also attended the book launch, at the headquarters of the Italian Jesuit journal La Civilta Cattolica.
China’s estimated 12 million Catholics are split between those belonging to the government-backed Chinese Catholic Patriotic Association, which is outside the Pope’s authority, and an underground church loyal to the Pope. Underground priests and parishioners are frequently detained and harassed.
The September deal was aimed at uniting the flock, regularising the status of seven bishops who were not recognised by Rome and thawing decades of estrangement between China and the Vatican.
But some of China’s underground faithful have deep reservations about the deal, seeing it as a sell-out to the communist government and a betrayal of their long loyalty to the pope.
Celli said he had no fears about the criticism that the deal sold out the underground church, saying: “I recognise there are positive elements for dialogue.”
“This provisional agreement is not just a point of arrival, but a point of departure for a more concrete and fruitful dialogue for both sides,” he said.
Celli, who also was the key negotiator in the Vatican’s Vietnam negotiations, said he began working on the China dossier in 1982, soon after the end of the Cultural Revolution. In those years, China severed official relations with Vatican, which was “literally inundated” with letters from bishops and priests who survived crackdowns by officially atheist governments.
The letters, written in remarkably good Latin, Celli said, gave the Holy See the first solid evidence of a Catholic Church divided into two communities.
Celli said his first meeting with Beijing authorities, at the Chinese embassy in Rome, was “not easy. The human rapport was tense, to say the least.”
A “limited sense of mutual trust” and poor communications impeded progress, which required a bridge to overcome the “rigidity of principles” on both sides, he said.
With the September 22 agreement, which established protocols for nominating bishops going forward, “undoubtedly we have increased mutual trust”, Celli said.
“The path of normalising the life of the church is still long,” he said, noting the difficulty of harmonising a church that is both fully Catholic and fully Chinese.
“Some would say I’m too optimistic,” Celli said. “I’ve never had illusions. But hope? Yes. I’m willing to welcome the surprise of the Lord, even in China.”